eXTReMe Tracker

Mommybrain

Am I Depriving the World of the Next Mozart?

Music hour in the Muller house

Most nights this is how Thor decompresses when we first get home from work. He sits down at the piano and starts belting out some Elvis Costello, Elton John, Beatles. Quinn usually joins him on one of the many supporting instruments — the strum stick (as seen above and which Quinn refers to as the “ti-tar”, aka guitar), the electronic drum pads, the mini-accordian, the harmonica, the triangle, the bongos, his own pint-sized baby grand piano… Sometimes I join in by dancing around the room. We’re not quite the von Trapp Family, but we have fun. And I know I should be grateful that Quinn is getting so much daily exposure to music. And I am. Why then, do I have a cloud of guilt hanging over me because I don’t yet have him in piano lessons?

It’s the same guilt that grips my stomach when I remember that he hasn’t had swimming lessons yet. Or Mandarin lessons. Or that he isn’t yet speaking Spanish fluently. Or that I want to enroll him in a tumbling or dance class. Or Acrosports. Or Karate. When I hear parents of younger children discussing the various classes they’ve already experienced with their kids or speaking fluently in a second language with their kids I’m overcome with panic. I tell myself: My child will never learn math because he can’t play Bach on the piano yet. Or my child might drown in my watering can because he hasn’t had swimming lessons yet. Or my child won’t be viable in the job market come 2022 because he won’t be able to speak Mandarin. Or my child might be the next Baryshnikov if not for the fact that his mom is a slacker.

Now, in my more rational moments I know these things to not be true. (Well, except maybe for the swimming lessons. I really need to get on that.) But in these other moments, these moments where I am so hard on myself, I am stunned at my inability to provide every opportunity for my child. Or at least one.

Where is this harsh judgement coming from? Some deep, personal regret of mine because I stopped dance classes after 4th grade only to pick them up again in college but with such a lack of confidence that I took beginner classes over and over, wishing, but never believing that I could be good enough to join the college modern dance troupe? Or is it some outside societal force that dictates to us in this age of opportunity what we should be doing to give our kids a competitive edge? That same force that makes the new parent believe that they must own the entire Baby Einstein DVD collection, or they must purchase every award-winning educational toy for each stage of development or they must make all their own babyfood from scratch and only using organic produce (I’m guilty of that one).

I’m sure it’s coming from all those places and probably even more. The question is, is there really a right or wrong way? In theory, I don’t believe there is — as long as your child is loved and nurtured they’ll turn out just fine. Right? Or is that just naive?

This entry was posted on Tuesday, May 23rd, 2006 at 8:58 pm and is filed under Uncategorized . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

There is 14 comments to this post.
  1. v Says:

    well he’ll turn out fine but he won’t get into harvard. just kidding. I mean, you don’t want him to go there anyway, right?

    maybe you should put him in a second language class. he’s at the best age to learn a new language — by the time he gets to high school it might be too late unless he’s really got a knack for it. of course, if you enroll him now then he might be more interested in learning it later, too. and swimming, lessons — he’ll have a lot of fun with that. otherwise, let him play. no one should grow up in a car being shuttled from one lesson to another.


  2. Thor Muller Says:

    To be fair, he does get Spanish at his school. He just isn’t fluent yet. What’s wrong with him???


  3. amylola Says:

    Ha! Yeah, who needs Harvard?

    The ironic thing is he was in a Spanish immersion day care for the past year yet he’s learned more Spanish in the past 2 months at his new pre school. I had assumed that being in an immersive environment from age 3 - 4 would’ve been enough to have him speaking fluently. But I agree, this is the time to tap into that multiple language part of his brain.

    And I know the swimming would be fun for him and is, ultimately, imperative for his safety.

    *sigh* I guess there’s no way around it. ..


  4. Jason Says:

    I think it’s important to see the big picture — is he an active child that is learning and growing in general? If so, then you’re doing your job. Ultimately, Quinn will have to figure out for himself what he likes and dislikes or what he’s passionate about learning. You can help him by exposing him to things, but I don’t think you need to feel responisble for his success at them.

    p.s. Harvard stinks. No one I know who went there liked it.


  5. Heather Says:

    As a trained immersion teacher, I feel it important to debunk a popular myth. Children do not learn languages faster than adults. In fact, adolescents and adults learn language more quickly that children. There are reasons that it appears that children learn more quickly . . . they spend more time each day working on their second language, their first language is weak, so the second language seems stong in comparison, and parents have a tendancy to glorify everything their children do, among others.


  6. amylola Says:

    Thanks, Jason. I know at heart that you’re right. But it’s a constant struggle between the two mommy personalities. The laid back mommy who doesn’t worry about these things and the uptight mommy who always worries about these things. I guess the key is to strike an agreement between the two.


  7. amylola Says:

    Thanks, Heather. You’re right — it is a popular myth. It’s what I always believed. I thought there was some theory about the best window to teach a child a second language was within the first five years. And that after that their capacity for learning it great diminishes.

    Your perspective is really interesting and enlightening. And you’re right about parents glorifying their childrens’ accomplishments! :) Is there research you’d recommend about the ease/difficulty of learning languages at different ages?


  8. ani Says:

    Oh, Mama. The happiness in your home is worth 10 Harvard educations. Maybe it would help to set a goal for Q to have had a few swim lessons before Seattle?


  9. amylola Says:

    Thanks, An. And that’s good, bite-sized advice. I think I can manage that. :)


  10. Heather Says:

    Amy,
    This is only one quick website . . . most everything I have studied on this topic I have read in French (I have a degree in French education). Here is one website that I found that covers many of the arguments I put forward. You can easily substitute Spanish for English, the theory is the same.


  11. Heather Says:

    Ahh! I didn`t attach the link!
    http://www.ncela.gwu.edu/pubs/ncrcdsll/epr5.htm


  12. amylola Says:

    Thanks, Heather! I’ll check it out.


  13. SydneySteve Says:

    With our three children we found that it was best to pick one or two areas that are both ‘useful’ and interesting to the child (e.g. music; second language), then stick with it for the long-haul. I believe too many parents try to expose their children to ‘everything’ in brief sound-bites only to burn them out on most things and leave them with superficial, and therefore impractical, experiences.


  14. amylola Says:

    Thanks, Steve! I think you’re right. And he’s getting Spanish at school so I guess the second language is taken care of for now.

    I think I’ll look into Suzuki piano for after the summer.


Leave a Reply

Kiss
photo by Thomas Hawk
Nav
Bio

Raising a Kid
I'm Quinn's mom. He's basically The Cutest Kid in the Known Universe. Ok, I know, your kid's cute too, but this one's mine. He was born in March of 2002 and came home from the hospital to a shower of Cherry Blossoms.

Founding Companies
In January 2007 Thor & I joined forces with Lane Becker of Adpative Path to found Get Satisfaction. Previous to Get Satisfaction I was a founding partner of Rubyred Labs, a design driven Internet product development firm where we made cool stuff and enjoyed breakfast, particularly when it involved cereal, coffee and grapefruit. Jonathan Grubb, our RRL partner defected to L.A. to shack up with and marry the awesome Kestrin.

Keeping the Peace
All this has left me craving a nap, but I still somehow manage to find time to travel with my brilliant and adorable husband (and sometimes my friends), experiment in the kitchen, and hit the town with my gorgeous, smart, single gal pals who are in search of kind, eligible men (I know you're out there...)

www.flickr.com
Amylola's photos More of Amylola's photos